Tomos Attewell
Wales has great startups. What happens after the applause?
Ask anyone who works with Welsh founders where the next wave of startups is, and the answer is usually the same: there aren't enough of them. I understand why people say it, but I think the bigger problem comes afterwards. Wales is good at starting and celebrating businesses. Where we seem to fall short is helping them grow, succeed and stay.
What happens to the award winners?
Across national, regional and local competitions, there’s no shortage of celebration for ambitious, innovative businesses in Wales. An award marks one moment, though. It says little about the following five or ten years and what entrepreneurs need to get there.
My initial research has identified 184 award-winning entries across six schemes between 2022 and 2026. That is 61 national, 51 regional and 72 local entries, covering 162 distinct companies and organisations. It isn't a complete record, but it gives us real businesses to follow.
Some will have raised investment, expanded abroad and created jobs. Others will have been acquired, stayed small or stopped trading. None of these outcomes is wrong. A good exit is a real achievement, and not every business needs to be international. But if we want to know how strong the ecosystem is, we need to follow all of these journeys, not just a moment of recognition in their life.
"Starting a business is the beginning of the story. It shouldn't be where our ambition ends."
Starting versus scaling
The wider figures point the same way. Wales had 100,420 active VAT or PAYE-registered enterprises in 2024, down 1.8% on the year before. There were 10,105 new enterprises, a rate of 10.1% against 11.1% across the UK. Five-year survival for businesses born in 2019 was 38.1%, just below the UK's 38.4%.
Most businesses never become large employers, and many are perfectly successful as small companies. For those that want to scale, the path is much harder, and longer. The ScaleUp Institute's 2025 Wales ScaleUp Index found 1,200 scale-ups and a further 610 scaling businesses, generating £19.6 billion and employing more than 121,000 people. Wales has a solid base of growing companies. What we don't know is how to produce more of them, or what happens to those that show early promise and never make the jump.
The missing middle
After the first customers are won and the product works, a business needs something different. That might be £500,000 to develop the product and enter a new market, experienced commercial leadership, international customers, specialist hires or a larger round to expand or acquire. This is where an ecosystem is tested: whether the business can find the right investors, networks and talent, and raise follow-on funding when the first round runs out. If it can't, the founder may decide growth would be easier somewhere else.
In Wales we put a lot of energy into supporting and celebrating early-stage businesses. We put less energy into understanding what happens when they want to become something bigger than that.
Does Wales keep the businesses it celebrates?
A company expanding beyond Wales is not the same as one leaving it. A business can build international operations, take overseas investment and serve global customers while keeping its headquarters and staff here. That should be celebrated. An acquisition isn't automatically a loss either, as it can reward founders, create opportunities for employees and give the business a platform to grow.
But unfortunately some companies outgrow what Wales can offer. They need a different investment market, a bigger customer base or a more established network, and they move their headquarters or key operations to places that can serve them better. Their economic value goes with them. What we’d really like to know is how many award winners have gone international while staying rooted in Wales, how many have exited and how many have relocated. We don't yet have the data to say, which is why the research is worth doing.
"In Wales we put a lot of energy into supporting and celebrating early-stage businesses and less into understanding what happens when they want to become something bigger than that."
Funding is just part of the answer
Wales has made progress on finance. The Development Bank of Wales, the Investment Fund for Wales, angel networks and a newer generation of early-stage investors all play a role, and public money has helped where private capital hasn't. But a healthy ecosystem can't depend on a handful of institutions. It needs experienced angels, venture funds, private investors and lenders at every stage, and follow-on capital to pay for expansion.
Money isn't enough on its own. Growing businesses need people around them who can open doors to customers, international markets and commercial expertise. Founders who have done it before are well placed to help, through investment, mentoring, introductions or starting new ventures. An ecosystem gets stronger when success creates opportunities for others. Just Eat founder David Buttress once said to us, “Wales needs some big exits” and he was right because success breeds success.
Measuring what happens next
We're good at counting business births, announcing investment rounds and celebrating those who show promise. But we should also track what follows: how many recognised startups have become substantial employers, expanded internationally, attracted private investment, exited or stayed in Wales, and how many stall before they reach sustainable growth. And most importantly: why and what can we do about it?
Survival and success are different things. One business may survive ten years without growing much, another may exit after five, and a third may become an international company with a major Welsh operation. They shouldn't be treated as the same outcome. Nor has a company failed just because it no longer trades under its original name. It may have been acquired or merged. What matters is the journey, not whether the company still exists. Each business is on its own unique path.
The organisations behind Wales's awards could help here. If they followed up with past winners after three, five and ten years, the awards would become a source of long-term insight into growth, investment, exits and economic impact.
Looking for answers beyond Wales
At GlobalWelsh, we see the Welsh diaspora as a huge resource that could play a much bigger part in the country's economic future. Not to be underestimated, there are thousands (more like hundreds of thousands) of Welsh founders, investors and business leaders around the world who have experience, networks, capital and market access that Welsh businesses could use. The challenge is finding and connecting to them. That’s what we do.
For example, a company entering the US could be introduced to a Welsh entrepreneur who has already built a business there. A founder looking for investment might find an angel in the global Welsh community. A scale-up could learn from someone who has done international expansion before. All these people will be connected to Wales and want to see Welsh businesses succeed.
It’s never just about bringing money back. It is about using the knowledge and relationships that already exist, so that Welsh businesses aren't limited by the size of the home market or the capital available within it.
Starting is only the beginning
In summary, Wales still needs new founders and a strong pipeline of ambitious companies. But we also need to look at what happens next. We already have a way of identifying promising businesses. The next step is following them: who scales, who attracts investment, who goes international, who exits, who stays, and what we can learn from those who don't make it.
We should be asking whether our businesses can get the finance, talent, experience, customers and networks they need, whether Wales keeps the benefits when they succeed, and whether successful founders are helping the next generation. If not, why not?
Wales doesn't lack ambition, ideas or businesses worth celebrating. But celebrating a business at one point in its journey isn't the same as helping it succeed over the long term. Starting a business is the beginning of the story. It shouldn't be where our ambition ends.
Discover GlobalWelsh Connect
Become part of a growing online network of Welsh people working together for the good of Wales by supporting others, exploring business opportunities and sharing knowledge.
Discover GlobalWelsh Connect